CHARMING LITTLE HIDEAWAY
This charming two-bedroom cottage near East Beach sits just across the street from a 400 foot-pier which extends over the marsh on the Bald Head Creek. Small and cozy, this home has a perfectly sized kitchen and enough dining seats for your whole party. This home is a duplex with the shared wall being the outer garage walls, and features a reverse floor plan — with a bunk bed (full bed on the bottom) bedroom on the lower floor and queen bedroom with en suite upstairs along with the kitchen and living area. Very well equipped. Step right across the street to enjoy a serene view of the marsh from the Keeper's Landing dock.
Finder's Keepers rents Sunday to Sunday in the summer. Enter a Sunday date in the availability box to the right to get a rate in the summer.
The BHI Club is optional, based on a first-come, first-served basis. For information on BHI club access and rates, contact the club directly at bhiclub.net.
The Shoal's Club is not an option.
For guest safety and property protection, cameras may be in place. No cameras are placed inside, or with any view of the interior of the property. Guest privacy is paramount, cameras are installed primarily as a theft deterrent and to protect the property.
Items pictured in rental home photography may or may not be available for rental guest use, I.E. fireplaces, water toys etc. If you have a specific question, please ask.
Always love being at BHI. Finders Keepers is beautifully kept-near the marsh and close to the beach.
Finders Keepers was a wonderful weekend escape to the East side of the island! A first time trip for many in my group and the accommodations were perfect! We are already looking forward to booking our next stay!
This was a perfect place for us and our two boys. The house is well appointed and had everything we needed. The dock was beautiful at night and our fishing loving boys couldn’t stay away. We have stayed in many places around the island and it would be hard to pick a favorite but we definitely enjoyed the proximity to East Beach and Mike's Bites!
We certainly enjoyed our visit on BHI! Thank you for making everything so easy and accommodating our requests! Finders Keepers was just right for us, cannot think of a thing we would change.
Keepers was the perfect set up for my family’s spring break. The location was wonderful and the accommodations were just as suitable. We appreciated the cleanliness, orderliness, and thoughtfulness from Tiffany’s.
We used Finders Keepers as an overflow house for our adult children over Thanksgiving. The location was perfect for us. The Keepers Landing section of BHI is quiet with low cart and pedestrian traffic. A peaceful environment. Almost no ambient light at night which makes the star scape breathtakingly beautiful. The house was clean, well-maintained, and had most of what we needed. Ideal for 4 guests, not sure how the unit would live with more. All kitchen and electronic devices worked fine - golf cart accommodates six. Instructions were clear. We did not need to reach out to Tiffany during our stay. All in all, very satisfied with our stay and would recommend.
The location is ideal for Bald Head with easy access to basically everything, especially East Beach. The walking trails and dock are ideal for sunsets and the neighborhood is quiet and tucked away... The management from Tiffany's Beach Rentals made it so easy from the first step through the end. I was shocked how accessible they were.
Tiffany is an absolute dream to work with. She is very responsive and answers questions thoroughly. The home was the prefect size for our family of 5 and the neighbors were nice as well! We will be back!
Finders Keepers was darling. The reverse floor plan was nice as the downstairs was a little dark due to the tree canopy but great for sleeping. kitchen is really small but efficient. The bathrooms look like they had been recently remodeled and were very nice. Golf cart was great. Love the Keepers landing area as it is close to the beach and the Marsh boardwalk in the community." Charla - May 2024
"Nice location, clean, well stocked. Would recommend!
Great two bedroom rental. Clean and stocked with towels and extras. Nice neighborhood on BHI. Tiffany's does a wonderful job of having everything ready, providing help and answering questions, etc.
We had a fantastic experience at our vacation rental!
We had a wonderful experience staying at this property. We have been coming to the island for 25 years but have never stayed this far east. It was very comfortable for 2 couples and 2 dogs.
Finders Keepers was the perfect spring getaway! The cottage was very clean, well stocked, and included beautiful updated bathrooms. With bedrooms/baths on each floor, it was a perfect getaway for two couples, or a family with children.
We were very impressed with the accommodations and the staff at Tiffany's Beach Rentals. I was able to contact them after hours with any questions that arose.
Tiffany’s Beach Rentals are always the best! We’ve tried multiple rental companies on BHI and the design, quality, and cleanliness are always most impressive with Tiffany’s. Finders Keepers was in a great location in relation to East Beach and we loved having access to the marsh. The common spaces had plenty of room for our family of four adults and three children although the bedrooms were a little tight as we had and infant and toddler we were trying to squeeze into the rooms as well.
Finders Keepers was perfect for me and my family this summer. We were able to hit the beach, enjoy the Island, and fish off of the awesome dock at Keeper's Landing. It was a magical week in a great home!
We absolutely love this home! It is so clean, beautifully decorated and is in a great location. My son loved fishing off the dock and the rest of us loved how quiet the community was. We can’t wait to visit again!!
Perfect spring break. Clean, well stocked, wonderful location. This is our second stay at Finders Keepers. We love that it is dog friendly. The private pier was a fun fishing location and a beautiful place to observe Bald Head Island’s natural beauty. Tiffany’s was very responsive and made the rental experience a breeze!
This home is in a quiet neighborhood near the marsh and beach. There's a sweet front porch and back patio with a charcoal grill, which we loved! The bathrooms in the house are very nice and the showers are spacious. The sofa is comfortable and there is a large dining room table. They allow dogs, which is great! All the floors are hardwood or another hard surface (no rugs), which I like. We were very pleased with the house and its condition- we definitely recommend staying here.
The house was amazing! It was very clean and in great condition.
Our stay was great, Tiffany's crew was very responsive to us. The kitchen was stocked with all needed pans, plates, etc. We recommend this house and rental company! The location is great and the golf carts were a blast! Thank you!
We loved the location and simplicity of this house; it was very clean and comfortable. Tiffany's Rentals was a professional and helpful group. We are very happy with our experience and would rent again!
We loved the updated bathrooms and new beach chairs! The location of the house is great and Tiffany was very responsive and helpful
I just wanted to say thanks again for helping us arrange yet another fabulous Bald Head island getaway this week. We love keepers landing and finders keeper certainly had met all of our needs. We appreciate your staff and their fast, friendly service.
